Favorite Amish Cooking Recipes
August 8, 2024
One of the best reasons to visit Ohio’s Amish Country is the food. The Amish are known for hearty, delicious, family-style meals. At weddings they often dine on fried chicken, mashed potatoes, stuffing, salad, cake or cupcakes, fruit, and ice cream. With just a few recipes, you can enjoy Amish cooking in your own home. Here are a few to get you started. Donna’s Premier Lodging includes an authentic recipe every month in their newsletter. Sign up
here
to add to your list of Amish cooking recipes.
When you stay at Donna’s Premier Lodging, you are treated to a hot Amish-inspired breakfast every morning. Recreating these recipes together at home is a great way to remember all the fun you had on your Ohio Amish Country getaway.
When you stay at Donna’s Premier Lodging, you are treated to a hot Amish-inspired breakfast every morning. Recreating these recipes together at home is a great way to remember all the fun you had on your Ohio Amish Country getaway.
Amish-Style Mashed Potatoes
This one is a favorite of the innkeeper. Her family has been making mashed potatoes this way since she was a little girl.
Ingredients:
Directions:
Amish Noodle Casserole
Casseroles are the ultimate easy dinner. This recipe makes enough for the whole family to have a second helping. This particular recipe follows the Amish tradition but you can play around to make it your own. Use chicken instead of beef, try a different style of noodle, add vegetables, or use a different flavor of condensed soup. Play around with the recipe until your find your family’s favorite version.
Ingredients:
Amish Peanut Butter Spread
Peanut butter is one of the world’s perfect foods. The Amish have found a way to make it even better. Sometimes called “church spread,” this peanut butter recipe has tasty uses beyond a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Try it alone on bread or add a dollop to the top of your ice cream.
Ingredients:
No-Bake Amish Dessert
Do you ever find yourself craving a cool, refreshing dessert? The Amish have perfected this dessert that is great for family gatherings or pot lucks.
Ingredients:
Directions:
This one is a favorite of the innkeeper. Her family has been making mashed potatoes this way since she was a little girl.
Ingredients:
- Potatoes
- ½ stick butter
- 4 ounces cream cheese
- ¼ cup sour cream
- ½ cup milk
Directions:
- Peel the potatoes and cut into chunks.
- Put the potato chunks in a medium kettle. Add 1 cup of water.
- Simmer the potato chunks until they are tender when pierced by a fork.
- Drain and mash the potato chunks.
- Add the remaining ingredients to the mashed potato chunks. Mash again until everything is nice and fluffy.
- Some types of potatoes may require more milk to get the desired consistency. Add small amounts of extra milk while continuing to mash if necessary.
- Served with browned butter or gravy. Delicious!
Amish Noodle Casserole
Casseroles are the ultimate easy dinner. This recipe makes enough for the whole family to have a second helping. This particular recipe follows the Amish tradition but you can play around to make it your own. Use chicken instead of beef, try a different style of noodle, add vegetables, or use a different flavor of condensed soup. Play around with the recipe until your find your family’s favorite version.
Ingredients:
- 500 g egg noodles (or pasta of your choice)
- 1 tbsp olive oil
- 1 onion, chopped
- 2 tsp garlic, crushed
- 750 grams lean ground beef
- 600 grams condensed tomato soup
- 600 grams condensed mushroom soup
- 1 cup milk
- ½ tsp paprika
- ½ tsp dried parsley
- Salt and black pepper to taste
- Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
- Add water to a large pot and set to high on the stove.
- Spray a large oven dish with cooking spray.
- Once the water is boiling, cook the noodles according to the instructions on the package.
- Heat olive oil over medium high heat in a sauté pan.
- Sauté the onion and garlic in the pan until soft.
- Add the ground beef to the onion and garlic mixture. Sauté until beef is cooked through.
- Drain noodles once cooked and return to the pot.
- Add cooked meat, onion, and garlic mixture to the noodles and stir.
- Add both soups and the milk to the noodle mixture. Stir thoroughly.
- Season with salt and pepper to taste.
- Put entire mixture in oven dish. Sprinkle the top with paprika and parsley.
- Bake for 25-30 minutes.
Amish Peanut Butter Spread
Peanut butter is one of the world’s perfect foods. The Amish have found a way to make it even better. Sometimes called “church spread,” this peanut butter recipe has tasty uses beyond a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Try it alone on bread or add a dollop to the top of your ice cream.
Ingredients:
- 1 cup light corn syrup
- ½ cup smooth peanut butter
- ¼ cup marshmallow crème
- Mix all three ingredients in a bowl until completely mixed together.
- Enjoy!
- Store any leftovers (if there are any) in an air-tight container.
No-Bake Amish Dessert
Do you ever find yourself craving a cool, refreshing dessert? The Amish have perfected this dessert that is great for family gatherings or pot lucks.
Ingredients:
- 2 ½ cups graham cracker crumbs
- ½ cup melted butter
- ¼ cup sugar
- 8 ounces cream cheese, softened
- ½ cup powdered sugar
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- 1 ½ cups heavy whipping cream (can substitute 8 ounces of Cool Whip if you prefer)
- 2 cans pie filling (cherry, blueberry, raspberry, and blackberry are great options)
Directions:
- Crush the graham crackers into crumbs.
- Mix the crumbs with the melted butter and sugar to form the crust.
- Press the crust mixture into the bottom of a 9X13” dish. Set the dish aside.
- Beat the cream cheese until creamy.
- Add the powdered sugar and vanilla extract to the cream cheese and mix well.
- Add heavy whipping cream to the cream cheese mixture. Beat on high speed until thick and creamy. Make sure to scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl with a spoon to get consistent creaminess throughout.
- Use a spoon to put large dollops of the cream cheese mixture on top of the graham cracker crust. Carefully spread to make an even layer.
- Spread your pie filling of choice on top of the cream cheese mixture.
- Refrigerate for a couple of hours before serving. Keep leftovers refrigerated.
One of the highlights of visiting Ohio’s Amish Country is discovering the abundance of fresh, locally grown produce available throughout the region. From roadside stands and farm markets to country stores and orchards, there are plenty of opportunities to enjoy seasonal fruits and vegetables. Whether you're planning a weekend getaway or a longer stay at Donna’s Premier Lodging, exploring the area's produce markets is a wonderful way to experience the flavors and traditions of Amish Country. Troyer Country Market 5201 County Road 77, Millersburg, OH 44654 www.troyerscountrymarket.com A favorite stop for both locals and visitors, Troyer Country Market offers a wide selection of fresh seasonal produce, along with Amish-made cheeses, baked goods, bulk foods, and specialty items. Depending on the time of year, you'll find everything from sweet corn and tomatoes to peaches, melons, and pumpkins. The market provides a true Amish Country shopping experience and is a great place to stock up on fresh ingredients for your stay. Hershberger’s Farm & Bakery 5452 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654 www.hershbergersfarmandbakery.com Hershberger’s is one of the most popular destinations in Amish Country, known for its bakery, petting farm, and seasonal produce. Visitors can browse fresh fruits and vegetables, locally made products, flowers, and more while enjoying a fun family-friendly atmosphere. It's an excellent stop for those looking to combine fresh produce shopping with a memorable Amish Country experience. Miller’s Farm Market 3463 OH-39, Millersburg, OH 44654 www.millersfarmmarketberlin.com Known for its commitment to quality and freshness, Miller’s Farm Market offers a variety of locally grown fruits and vegetables throughout the growing season. Their market has become a popular stop for visitors seeking fresh produce and other farm-fresh products. Whether you're looking for sweet corn, tomatoes, peppers, or seasonal favorites, you'll find plenty of options to choose from. Hillcrest Orchard 2474 Walnut St., Walnut Creek, OH 44687 www.cometowalnutcreekohio.com/portfolio-view/hillcrest-orchard Family-owned and operated by the Merle Hershberger family, Hillcrest Orchard in Walnut Creek grows 22 varieties of apples and 12 varieties of peaches on 75 acres of orchards. Visitors can shop for orchard-fresh fruit, locally grown produce, meats and cheeses, and Hillcrest’s popular fresh apple cider. During the fall season, guests can also enjoy festive decorations and beautiful views of Mud Valley from the orchard’s scenic overlook. Hillcrest Orchard is currently closed for the season and will reopen on July 9, 2026. The market is open from mid-July through March. Ashery Country Store 8922 SR 241, Fredericksburg, OH 44627 www.asherycountrystore.com While best known for its bulk foods, deli, and specialty products, Ashery Country Store also carries locally grown produce throughout the growing season. It's an excellent place to find fresh ingredients while exploring one of Amish Country's most beloved country stores. The Best Time to Visit Fresh produce can be found throughout much of the year, but the peak season typically runs from July through September. During these months, visitors can enjoy sweet corn, tomatoes, green beans, peppers, peaches, melons, cucumbers, and many other farm-fresh favorites. Stay Close to the Fresh Flavors of Ohio’s Amish Country One of the advantages of staying at Donna’s Premier Lodging is being conveniently located near many of Amish Country’s most popular produce markets and farm stands. After a day of shopping for fresh fruits, vegetables, baked goods, and local specialties, you can return to the comfort of your cabin, cottage, suite, or villa and enjoy the peaceful surroundings that make Amish Country so special. Whether you're visiting during the height of summer harvest season or enjoying the colorful bounty of fall, Donna’s Premier Lodging places you in the heart of the region's freshest experiences. Ready to experience the fresh flavors of Ohio’s Amish Country for yourself? Donna’s Premier Lodging is located at 5523 East St., in Berlin. Call 330-893-3068 or visit DonnasOfBerlin.com .
Summer Fun in Ohio’s Amish Country: Events You Won’t Want to Miss Summer in Ohio’s Amish Country is filled with small-town charm, family fun, live entertainment, and unforgettable memories. From outdoor concerts and fireworks to festivals, food, and local art, there’s always something happening in and around Berlin and Holmes County during the warmer months. When you stay at Donna’s Premier Lodging, you’ll be perfectly located to experience all the excitement while still enjoying a relaxing retreat at the end of the day. Whether you’re planning a romantic getaway or a fun-filled weekend adventure, summer is the perfect time to visit Ohio’s Amish Country. Music on the Square – Downtown Berlin May 22-September 18, 2026 One of the most beloved summer traditions in Berlin is the “Music on the Square” concert series. Every Friday evening from May 22, 2026, through September 18, 2026, the heart of downtown Berlin comes alive with music from 7:00–9:00 PM (weather permitting). Enjoy a variety of musical styles including Gospel, Bluegrass, Broadway, Country, Folk, and Light Rock while gathering with friends and family on the town square. These free concerts are a great way to spend a summer evening while enjoying the welcoming atmosphere of Amish Country. Learn more here: https://www.visitberlinohio.com/music-on-the-square Berlin Harvest Festival & Rib Cook-Off – Downtown Berlin September 11–12, 2026 The Berlin Harvest Festival & Rib Cook-Off is one of the largest and most anticipated events of the year in Amish Country. This exciting weekend celebration features delicious BBQ ribs, live entertainment, fireworks, arts and crafts, local vendors, and a festive parade. Visitors from all over gather in Berlin to experience the fun, food, and community spirit that make this event such a favorite. If you’re visiting during September, this is definitely an event you won’t want to miss. Check for updates here: https://www.visitberlinohio.com/berlin-harvest-festival Thunder Over Holmes County – Historic Downtown Millersburg June 27, 2026 Celebrate summer and Independence Day festivities at Thunder Over Holmes County in Historic Downtown Millersburg. This family-friendly event features inflatables, games, activities for kids, touch-a-truck experiences, entertainment, and one of the area’s most exciting fireworks displays. It’s the perfect opportunity to spend the day exploring Millersburg before ending the evening with fireworks lighting up the summer sky. Fireworks typically begin around 9:45 PM. Learn more here: https://historicdowntownmillersburg.com/events Holmes County Art Festival – Historic Downtown Millersburg September 12, 2026 Art lovers will enjoy the Holmes County Art Festival held in Historic Downtown Millersburg. This juried art festival showcases talented regional and local artists along with live entertainment, performances, food trucks, and handcrafted goods. The festival creates a vibrant atmosphere where visitors can shop unique artwork, enjoy local creativity, and experience the artistic side of Ohio’s Amish Country. Learn more here: https://historicdowntownmillersburg.com/events Relax & Recharge at Donna’s Premier Lodging After a day of music, shopping, festivals, and family fun, there’s nothing better than returning to the comfort of Donna’s Premier Lodging. Our cabins, suites, villas, and cottages offer the perfect place to relax and recharge after enjoying the area’s summer activities. Whether you’re sipping coffee on the porch, unwinding in a Jacuzzi for two, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings, Donna’s Premier Lodging combines comfort, convenience, and the beauty of Amish Country all in one unforgettable stay. Donna’s Premier Lodging is the perfect home base for exploring everything Holmes County has to offer. Staying at Donna’s Premier Lodging puts you in the heart of Ohio’s Amish Country and all the fun summer activities it has to offer. Summer weekends fill quickly! Call 330-893-3068 or visit DonnasOfBerlin.com to make a reservation.
Outdoor Sights & Scenic Trails Near Ohio’s Amish Country
Explore Spring Greenhouses in Ohio’s Amish Country
One of the most memorable parts of visiting Ohio’s Amish Country is indulging in its incredible bakeries, where time-honored family recipes and from-scratch baking shine. When you stay at Donna’s Premier Lodging, you’re perfectly positioned to explore these outstanding bakeries and enjoy the comforting flavors that make the area so special. From flaky pie crust to melt-in-your-mouth donuts, these local favorites offer a delicious glimpse into Amish Country’s rich traditions — perfect for fueling a day of shopping or sightseeing. Don’t forget to grab a delicious donut or pastry to enjoy with your coffee back at your cozy suite or cabin at Donna’s Premier Lodging. Local Small Bakery Favorites Kauffman’s Country Bakery: Kauffman’s Country Bakery is a must-stop for anyone craving classic Amish baked goods, offering everything from fresh breads and cookies to donuts, cinnamon rolls, and their famous Dutch, fruit, and cream pies. Everything is made from scratch using simple ingredients, delivering authentic flavor in every bite. If you are a guest staying at Donna's Premier Lodging, on your day of arrival, you will get a sampling of Kauffman's cookies in your welcome bag. 4357 US-62, Millersburg, OH 44654 Miller’s Bakery: A beloved local favorite, Miller’s Bakery is well known for its fry pies, tarts, cinnamon raisin bread, and fresh donuts made daily. Their cream sticks and homestyle pastries make this small bakery a sweet stop worth seeking out during your Amish Country visit. 4280 Township Hwy 356, Millersburg, OH Bakeries Anchored in Amish Country Destinations Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery: At Hershberger’s Farm and Bakery, bakers start before sunrise crafting fresh breads, donuts, cinnamon rolls, cookies, pies, and their famous fry pies using family recipes. Made without preservatives and always from scratch, their baked goods deliver a freshness you can taste with every bite. 5452 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654 The Amish Door Bakery (Amish Door Village): Part of the larger Amish Door Village campus, The Amish Door Bakery is famous for its homemade donuts, cream sticks, and crowd-pleasing apple fritters, all handcrafted daily using high-quality ingredients. They also offer a wonderful selection of homemade pies with flaky crusts and rich fillings. 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH 44689 Make It a Sweet Getaway Exploring Amish Country bakeries is more than just a food experience, it’s a tradition rooted in care, craftsmanship, and comfort. When you stay at Donna’s Premier Lodging, you can savor these sweet stops by day and return to a peaceful, romantic retreat by night, making your Amish Country getaway truly unforgettable. Ready to plan your getaway? Donna’s Premier Lodging is located at 5523 East St., in Berlin. Call 330-893-3068 for information or to make a reservation. Visit the website at DonnasOfBerlin.com and find them on Facebook at Donna’s Premier Lodging.
A Romantic Valentine’s Day Weekend in Ohio’s Amish Country If you’re searching for the perfect Valentine’s Day getaway in Ohio, look no further than Donna’s Premier Lodging in Ohio’s Amish Country. Known for its peaceful scenery, cozy accommodations, and charming attractions, this region offers couples a truly romantic escape. From relaxing winery visits to live theater and scenic strolls through historic towns, Amish Country sets the stage for an unforgettable Valentine’s Day weekend. Why Ohio’s Amish Country Is Ideal for a Valentine’s Getaway Ohio’s Amish Country is a favorite destination for couples seeking a romantic weekend getaway without the crowds or stress of larger cities. The area’s slower pace encourages meaningful connection, making it an ideal choice for Valentine’s Day. Snow-covered hills, quiet back roads, and warm firesides create a naturally intimate atmosphere. Cozy & Romantic Accommodations for Couples One of the highlights of a Valentine’s weekend in Amish Country is Donna’s Premier Lodging. All accommodations feature private entrances, fireplaces, and in-room Jacuzzis—perfect for relaxation and reconnection. Whether you prefer a secluded cabin tucked into the hills or a charming suite near downtown Berlin, you’ll find accommodations that feel personal and peaceful. Visit Local Amish Country Wineries Spending an afternoon at a winery is a classic romantic experience, and Amish Country offers several beloved options. Couples can enjoy tastings and cozy indoor settings at Breitenbach Winery, Baltic Mill Winery, Sunny Slope Winery, and Hans’ Place. These wineries are ideal stops during a Valentine’s Day weekend, offering a relaxed environment to sip, savor, and enjoy time together. Enjoy Live Theater & Entertainment Add an evening of entertainment to your romantic getaway by attending a live performance. Ohio Star Theater, Amish Country Theater, and Amish Door Village offer engaging shows ranging from musical acts to comedy. Attending live theater together is a wonderful way to share laughter, make memories, and add variety to your Valentine’s itinerary. Stroll Through Charming Amish Country Towns A romantic Valentine’s weekend wouldn’t be complete without exploring the charming towns of Amish Country. Walking through downtown Berlin or Millersburg to browse local shops and soak in the area’s unique charm. Winter’s quieter pace makes it easy to explore at a relaxed speed. Plan Your Romantic Valentine’s Day Getaway in Ohio’s Amish Country What makes Ohio’s Amish Country so special is its focus on simplicity, comfort, and meaningful moments. From relaxing in a private Jacuzzi to sharing wine by the fireplace or enjoying a peaceful morning together, every experience feels intentional. A Valentine’s Day getaway here isn’t rushed—it’s centered on reconnecting and creating lasting memories. If you’re dreaming of a romantic Valentine’s Day weekend in Ohio, Donna’s Premier Lodging in Amish Country offers the perfect blend of relaxation, charm, and intimate experiences. It’s a destination where time slows down and every moment together matters. Ready to plan your romantic getaway? Donna’s Premier Lodging is located at 5523 East St., in Berlin. Call 330-893-3068 for information or to make a reservation. Visit the website at DonnasOfBerlin.com and find them on Facebook at Donna’s Premier Lodging.
Christmas in Amish Country is centered on faith, family, and meaningful time together. While many Amish join the wider world in observing Christmas on December 25—a sacred day honoring the birth of Jesus—they do so without the typical frills such as Christmas trees or flashy decorations. Instead, celebrations focus on family gatherings, homemade meals, simple gift exchanges, and shared fellowship. In addition to December 25, many Amish communities also honor Old Christmas on January 6, a tradition rooted in the older Julian calendar and still observed as Epiphany by some groups. Old Christmas is a quieter, more reflective holiday marked by family visits and special meals, rather than the busier festivities of December. Out of respect for these Holidays, many Amish-run businesses in the area are closed on both Christmas Day (Dec. 25) and Old Christmas (Jan. 6). Visitors will want to plan accordingly. Both celebrations reflect the Amish emphasis on faith, simplicity, and togetherness, offering a window into a meaningful holiday season that values people and tradition over spectacle.
Homestyle Dining in Ohio’s Amish Country
When the air turns crisp and the leaves change into brilliant shades of red, orange, and gold, Ohio’s Amish Country becomes one of the most beautiful fall destinations in the Midwest. October is the perfect time to visit, with scenic drives, seasonal festivals, and unique experiences.
Discover the heart of Ohio Amish Country at Mt. Hope Auctions. Find your next treasure, from fresh produce and livestock to antique farm equipment, and experience the authentic charm and community of a true rural tradition.
