Thanksgiving-Style Fixings Year-Round: Homestyle Dining in Ohio’s Amish Country
Homestyle Dining in Ohio’s Amish Country
There’s something special about Amish-style cooking — hearty meals made from scratch, recipes passed down through generations, and the kind of hospitality that makes you feel at home.
Whether you’re craving the comfort of mashed potatoes and gravy or a slice of homemade pie, these local favorites serve up that Thanksgiving-style warmth all year long.
Top Restaurants to Visit for Amish-Style Food:
Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant : “Where the Locals Eat”
When the doors first open at 5:30 a.m., you’re bound to find a line outside — and for good reason! Boyd & Wurthmann has been a downtown landmark in Berlin and it’s easy to see why! On any given day, you’ll find 15–20 different kinds of pie, depending on what’s in season. Guests return repeatedly for hearty homemade fixings like noodles over mashed potatoes, roast beef, fried ham, and classic chicken dinners.
- 4819 East Main Street, Berlin, OH
- https://boydandwurthmann.com
The Farmstead Restaurant: A True Amish Country Experience
Located just outside of downtown Berlin, the Berlin Farmstead celebrates everything we love about this region — warm gatherings and traditional family recipes. Enjoy a country-style lunch, or dinner featuring hot biscuits, garden-fresh salad bar plates, and legendary peanut butter pie. The “barn raising buffet” includes all the homestyle favorites such as mashed potatoes and gravy, dressing, green beans, creamed corn, and your choice of chicken, ham, roast beef, pork, or turkey.
- 4757 Township Rd 366, Millersburg, OH
- https://dhgroup.com/restaurants/berlin-farmstead-berlin-oh
East Main Kitchen: Comfort Food with a Twist
Tucked in the small town of Baltic, East Main Kitchen serves up big flavor with its signature comfort dishes. Favorites include fried buttermilk chicken smothered in gravy, oven-roasted turkey breast sliced thin and served alongside homemade gravy, and slow-roasted beef seasoned with a house blend. It’s comfort food at its finest — warm, filling, and made with heart.
- 108 E Main St, Baltic, OH
- https://eastmainkitchen.com
The Amish Door Restaurant: A Classic Country Gathering Place
Located in the heart of Wilmot, the Amish Door Restaurant is part of the renowned Amish Door Village, a charming destination known for its inviting atmosphere and delicious, traditional fare. The restaurant offers a wide variety of Amish and comfort food favorites, from mouthwatering fried chicken and homemade mashed potatoes to fresh vegetables and indulgent desserts. Guests can enjoy the popular “All-You-Can-Eat Salad Bar” along with hearty lunch and dinner specials, each prepared with care using locally sourced ingredients and time-honored Amish recipes. Whether you’re savoring a warm bowl of soup, a freshly made sandwich, or a comforting entrée, every dish is served with genuine Amish hospitality.
- 1210 Winesburg St, Wilmot, OH 44689
- www.amishdoor.com
Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen: A True Taste of Amish Country
Stop in at Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen in Mount Hope for a casual, heartwarming dining experience that feels like home. Best known for its famous buffet, Mrs. Yoder’s serves up crispy fried chicken made fresh daily, along with Amish favorites like homemade mashed potatoes, noodles, fresh vegetables, and a plentiful salad bar. The buffet and menu feature dishes made with locally sourced meats and produce, including homegrown, seasonal fruits and vegetables whenever possible. From fried chicken and roast beef to pork chops, perch, and homemade pies, every bite celebrates authentic Amish Country flavor. Whether you’re here for lunch or dinner, you won’t leave hungry… and once you taste it, you’ll be back!
- 8101 State Route 241, Mt. Hope, OH 44660
- www.mrsyoderskitchen.com
Don’t forget to savor the simple things! When you visit Amish Country, it’s not just about the scenery — it’s about the flavors that bring people together. Pull up a chair, pass the mashed potatoes, and enjoy a true taste of Ohio’s Amish Country.












